The Girls From Earth — A Reader’s Guide

(0 User reviews)   3593
In Category - Space Future
Emshwiller, Ed, 1925-1990 [Illustrator], Robinson, Frank M., 1926-2014 Project Gutenberg 2016 Not confirmed
Science fiction; Short stories; Space colonies -- Fiction Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words 10,438
Reading time 46 min
Text sections 2

The Girls From Earth — A Reader’s Guide can be approached with a clearer sense of reading commitment from its source measurements: 10,438 words, 46 min estimated reading time, and 2 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 15.0 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Science fiction,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

Frank M. Robinson's 1952 story opens with colonists on an alien world hauling a raft while their yllumphs watch; later, a woman is coerced into emigration. The excerpts contrast frontier labor with bureaucratic coercion, raising questions about choice and gender roles.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.5/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

Karl looked out of the corner of his eye at Hill and felt a vague wave of uneasiness. Hill was a big, thick man wearing the soiled clothes and bristly stubble of a man who was used to living alone and who liked it. But once he took a wife, he would probably have to keep himself in clean clothes and shave every few days. It was even possible that the woman might object to Hill letting his yllumph share the hut.

The path was getting crowded, more of the colonists coming onto the main path from the small side trails.

Hill broke the silence first. "I wonder what they'll be like."

Karl looked wise and nodded knowingly. "They're Earthwomen, Joe. _Earth!_"

It was easy to act as though he had some inside information, but Karl had to admit to himself that he actually knew very little about it. He was a Second System colonist and had never even seen an Earthwoman. He had heard tales, though, and even discounting a large percentage of them, some of them must have been true. Old Grundy at the rocket office, who should know about these things if anybody did, seemed disturbingly lacking on definite information, though he had hinted broadly enough. He'd whistle softly and wink an eye and repeat the stories that Karl had already heard; but he had nothing _definite_ to offer, no real facts at all.

Some of the other colonists whom they hadn't seen for the last few months shouted greetings, and Karl began to feel some of the carnival spirit. There was Jenkins, who had another trapping line fifty miles farther up the Karazoo; Leonard, who had the biggest farm on Midplanet; and then the fellow who specialized in catching and breaking in yllumphs, whose name Karl couldn't remember.

"They say they're good workers," Hill said.

Karl nodded. "Pretty, too."

They threaded their way through the crowded and muddy streets. Landing City wasn't big, compared to some of the cities on Altair, where he had been raised, but Karl was proud of it. Some day it would be as big as any city on any planet--maybe even have a population of ten thousand people or more.

"Joe," Karl said suddenly, "what's supposed to make women from Earth better than women from any other world?"

Hill located a faint itch and frowned. "I don't know, Karl. It's hard to say. They're--well, sophisticated, glamorous."

Karl absorbed this in silence. Those particular qualities were, he thought, rather hard to define.

The battered shack that served as rocket port office and headquarters for the colonial office on Midplanet loomed up in front of them. There was a crowd gathered in front of the building and they forced their way through to see what had caused it.

"We saw this the last time we were here," Hill said.

"I know," Karl agreed, "but I want to take another look." He was anxious to glean all the information that he could.

It was a poster of a beautiful woman leaning toward the viewer. The edges of the poster were curling and the colors had faded during the last six months, but the girl's smile seemed just as inviting as ever. She held a long-stemmed goblet in one hand and was blowing a kiss to her audience with the other. Her green eyes sparkled, her smile was provocative. A quoted sentence read: "I'm from _Earth_!" There was nothing more except a printed list of the different solar systems to which the colonial office was sending the women.

She was real pretty, Karl thought. A little on the thin side, maybe, and the dress she was wearing would hardly be practical on Midplanet, but she had a certain something. Glamour, maybe?

A loudspeaker blared.

"All colonists waiting for the wife draft assemble for your numbers! All colonists...."

There was a jostling for places and then they were in the rapidly moving line. Grundy, fat and important-looking, was handing out little blue slips with numbers on them, pausing every now and then to tell them some entertaining bit of information about the women. He had a great imagination, nothing else.

Karl drew the number 53 and hurried to the grassy lot beside the landing field that had been decorated with bunting and huge welcome signs for the new arrivals. A table was loaded with government pamphlets meant to be helpful to newly married colonists. Karl went over and stuffed a few in his pockets. Other tables had been set out and were loaded with luncheon food, fixed by the few colonial women in the community. Karl caught himself eyeing the women closely, wondering how the girls from Earth would compare with them.

The story begins not with a rocket launch but with mud, rope, and a balking beast called an yllumph. Karl Allen and Joseph Hill strain to beach a raft on the Karazoo river, their mounts watching critically from the shade. The setting is rustic, almost pioneer—yet the men are hurrying to meet a ship at Landing City, hoping to secure wives from Earth. The opening establishes a tone of wry practicality: the colonists know the work is hard, and they joke about spoiling the women before they arrive.

This is not a tale of sleek spaceships or heroic explorers. The details—leather saddles, furs tied behind the saddle, a raft of parampa logs—ground the story in a specific, handmade world. The men's concern about being 'crossed off the list' hints at a bureaucratic system behind the frontier roughness.

Two Worlds, One Problem

The story's subtitle poses a puzzle: how to arrange marriages when men live in one solar system and women in another, and neither will relocate. The excerpts show two distinct societies. On the colony planet, men farm, trap, and haul rafts; they speak of 'applying for a wife' as a practical transaction. Back on Earth, women like Suzanne Carstens are rounded up by the Colonization Board, given a choice between emigration or prison. The contrast is stark: the colonists see wives as partners for work and family, while the women are coerced into leaving their homes.

The narrative voice shifts between these worlds. The colony scenes are filled with physical detail—mud, rope, the weight of a raft. The Earth scenes are sleek and menacing: a brownstone office, a suave young man, a battery of chairs. The women recognize each other; they have been betrayed by someone who sold their phone numbers. The story does not explain how the system works, but the imbalance of power is clear.

The Weight of a Line

Robinson uses physical labor to define the colony setting. The opening scene is built around a single action: pulling a raft ashore. The men count together—'One! Two!'—and the river threatens to tear the raft away. The yllumphs, described as 'tiny' and 'reluctant,' add a touch of absurdity; they are not helpful beasts but independent creatures that watch critically. This detail suggests a world where even domesticated animals have their own will.

The labor is not romanticized. Karl and Joe are tired, muddy, and worried about time. They discuss furs and trading rockets, revealing a subsistence economy. The colony is not a paradise but a place of constant effort. The men's desire for wives is partly practical—they need help on the farms—but the story also hints at loneliness. Karl brings furs against the cold, a small gesture that Joe dismisses as spoiling the women.

A Choice of Planets

The later excerpt shows the women at a transfer shed, being assigned to colony planets. The setting is impersonal: 'vast and somber,' with desks, filing cabinets, and clicking machinery. The women sit huddled at the edges, clutching small suitcases. Phyllis silently swears she will never leave her new planet, no matter what. The officials read off options: Sunside, with its warm climate and flower-growing; other planets with different ratios of men to women.

The women are allowed to choose, but the choice is constrained. Suzanne's earlier reaction—'I love to travel!'—is a hollow joke. The story does not show what happens after they board the ship, but the tone suggests resignation. The women are not adventurers; they are survivors. The transfer shed is a liminal space, between the old life and an uncertain future.

Voice and Irony

Robinson's prose is efficient, with a dry humor that undercuts the drama. When Suzanne is told she faces ten years in jail, she thinks of losing her apartment—'her symbol of security.' The detail is small but telling: her priorities are shaped by a world where a lease matters more than freedom. The narrator does not comment, letting the irony speak.

The dialogue is similarly pointed. The Colonization Board representative says the colonists 'offer you—security,' stressing the word as if it is a gift. But the women have no real choice. The story's structure—alternating between the men's hopeful preparations and the women's coercion—creates a tension that is never resolved in the excerpts. The reader is left to wonder whether the marriage scheme will work, and at what cost.

The excerpts of The Girls from Earth present a science fiction story that is less about technology than about social arrangements. The colony is built on manual labor and mutual need; Earth is a place of surveillance and coercion. Robinson does not take sides, but the juxtaposition raises questions about consent, gender roles, and the price of survival. Readers should pay attention to the small details—the yllumphs, the furs, the hat box—that reveal character and world. The story's ending is not included here, but the journey is worth following.

That story about the raft-hauling colonists stayed with me, that quiet weight of impossible labor. It made me think of another one, The Moon Destroyers — Story, Setting & Ideas, where the same ache of being pressed into someone else’s plan lingers. We never really leave, do we, our choices wearing thin until they’re almost someone else’s.

There are no reviews for this eBook.

0
0 out of 5 (0 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
There are no comments for this eBook.

Reader reflection

How will you remember this book?

Save your reaction, strongest insight, and memorable passage.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

Where are you in your reading?

2

How much did you enjoy the reading experience?

3

Would you pass this book on to a friend?

4

How easy was the book to follow?

Related eBooks